Medicare Supplement Plans in New Jersey: What They Cover and When You Can Buy One
Medigap fills the gaps Original Medicare leaves — and in New Jersey, the right to buy one without a health review does not last. Here is what each plan covers, what the gaps actually cost in 2026, and the six-month window that decides your options for the rest of your life.
Sources linked per section: CMS, Social Security, and the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance. Last reviewed September 2026.
Example
A Mendham couple turns 65 in March. Both are healthy, both are still working part-time, and both decide to skip a supplement for now — Original Medicare seems to be covering things fine. Eighteen months later one of them is scheduled for a knee replacement, and they call about a Medigap policy.
By then, the carrier is allowed to ask about the knee. In New Jersey, it is also allowed to decline them.
That is the part most people do not find out until they need it. Medigap has one guaranteed window at the start, and outside it, carriers can review your health and say no. The decision you make at 65 is not easily reversed at 67.
What Medigap actually pays for
Original Medicare pays most of a covered bill and leaves the rest to you, with no annual cap on what “the rest” can reach. Medigap policies cover some or all of that remainder.
The 2026 gaps a Medigap policy is designed to fill:
| What Medicare leaves you | 2026 amount |
|---|---|
| Part A hospital deductible, per benefit period | $1,736 |
| Part A coinsurance, days 61–90 | $434/day |
| Part A coinsurance, lifetime reserve days | $868/day |
| Skilled nursing facility coinsurance, days 21–100 | $217/day |
| Part B annual deductible | $283 |
| Part B coinsurance, outpatient | 20% of the approved amount, uncapped |
The last line is the one that matters most. There is no out-of-pocket maximum in Original Medicare. Twenty percent of a large bill is a large number, and it repeats.
Source: CMS, 2026 Medicare Parts A & B premiums and deductibles, announced 14 November 2025.
Plan G, Plan N, and high-deductible G: the three most people are choosing between
Medigap plans are standardized by letter. A Plan G from one carrier covers exactly what a Plan G from another covers. What differs between carriers is price and rate history, not benefits.
Plan G
Covers every gap in the table above except the $283 Part B deductible. It also covers Part B excess charges, which arise when a provider does not accept Medicare’s approved amount as full payment.
If you want a predictable year: you pay the premium and the $283, and the plan handles essentially everything else Medicare-approved.
Plan N
Covers the same structure as Plan G with three differences: you pay up to $20 for an office visit, up to $50 for an emergency room visit that does not lead to admission, and Part B excess charges are not covered.
If you see a doctor a few times a year: the lower premium usually beats the copays. If you are in and out of specialists: run the arithmetic before assuming it does.
High-deductible Plan G
Identical benefits to Plan G, but the plan pays nothing until you have paid $2,950 in 2026 toward Medicare-approved cost-sharing. The Part A and Part B deductibles you pay count toward that figure.
If you can absorb a bad year: the premium difference can be substantial, and Original Medicare still pays its share from day one — you are not uninsured until you hit $2,950.
Plans C and F, and why you probably cannot buy one
Plans C and F also cover the Part B deductible, and you will see them in comparison charts. If you became eligible for Medicare on or after 1 January 2020, you cannot buy either one. They remain in force for people who had them.
The six-month window, and what happens after it closes
Your Medigap open enrollment period runs six months from the first month you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During it, carriers must sell you any plan they offer, at their standard rate, regardless of your health.
After it closes, New Jersey carriers may medically underwrite — review your health history and decline you, or charge more — unless you have a guaranteed issue right.
New Jersey does not have a birthday rule. Roughly 15 states give existing policyholders an annual window to switch plans without underwriting. New Jersey is not one of them, and this is the single most common error in online Medigap content about this state. Legislation to create continuous open enrollment has been introduced repeatedly — most recently in 2026 — and has not advanced. If you read somewhere that you can change plans each year around your birthday, that advice is for a different state.
The guaranteed issue situations
There is a defined list of circumstances in which a carrier must sell you a policy regardless of health. The common ones:
- Your employer group coverage is ending
- Your Medicare Advantage plan leaves Medicare, stops serving your area, or you move out of its service area
- Your Medigap carrier becomes insolvent or the policy ends through no fault of yours
- Trial right: you joined a Medicare Advantage plan when you first became eligible at 65, and you want to leave within the first 12 months
Most guaranteed issue rights run 63 days from the qualifying event. The date matters more than the reason.
If you are under 65
Federal rules do not guarantee Medigap access to people eligible through disability. New Jersey requires carriers to make coverage available anyway — one of the majority of states that does.
What a Medigap policy does not do
- It is not Part D. Medigap policies sold today do not include prescription drug coverage. You buy that separately, and skipping it creates a late enrollment penalty that follows you permanently.
- It does not work alongside Medicare Advantage. You have one or the other. If you have an Advantage plan, a Medigap policy cannot pay your costs under it.
- It does not cover dental, vision, or hearing.
- It does not cap what you pay for drugs. That is Part D’s job.
How Medigap prices are set, and why the cheapest quote is not the cheapest policy
Because benefits are standardized, carriers compete on price and on how they raise it. A policy priced attractively at 65 is not necessarily the one that is still reasonable at 78, and once you are past your open enrollment window, moving is not guaranteed.
Three things worth asking about any quote: the carrier’s rate increase history in New Jersey, whether the rate is set by attained age, issue age, or community rating, and whether the premium shown includes a household or paperless discount you would need to keep qualifying for.
Twenty-three insurers offered Medigap policies in New Jersey as of the state’s most recent published list. New Jersey’s State Health Insurance Assistance Program publishes rate charts by carrier and plan letter.
What this means if you are turning 65 in the Somerset Hills and Morris County towns
Two local considerations worth highlighting.
Your doctors. Medigap works with any provider who accepts Medicare, anywhere in the country — there is no network. If your physicians are in the Atlantic Health system at Morristown Medical Center or Overlook, a Medigap policy does not ask whether they are in network, because it does not have one. That is the central practical difference from Medicare Advantage.
Time spent elsewhere. If you spend part of the year in Florida or the Carolinas, the no-network point applies there too. Most Medigap plans, including G and N, also cover 80% of medically necessary emergency care abroad during the first 60 days of a trip, up to a lifetime limit.
FAQ
Can you buy a Medigap policy any time?
You can apply any time. Whether a carrier has to sell you one is a different question. Outside your six-month open enrollment window, and outside a guaranteed issue situation, a New Jersey carrier may review your health and decline you.
Does Medigap cover the Part B deductible?
Not on any plan available to people who became eligible on or after 1 January 2020. In 2026 that deductible is $283, and you pay it before Plan G or Plan N pays anything.
Is Plan G the same at every company?
The benefits are identical by law. The premium is not, and neither is how fast it rises.
Can you switch from Medicare Advantage to Medigap later?
Sometimes. If you are in your first 12 months of an Advantage plan you joined at 65, you have a trial right. Outside that, you can apply, but underwriting usually applies in New Jersey.
What happens if you keep working past 65?
If your employer has 20 or more employees and you stay on that plan, you can generally delay Part B without penalty, and your Medigap window starts when you eventually enrol. If the employer has fewer than 20, the rules change. Check out the enrollment hub for more info.
Do you need Part D if you take no prescriptions?
Almost certainly yes. The penalty for going without creditable drug coverage is permanent, and it is calculated from how long you waited.
Have a question about your own situation?
Have a question about your own situation?
Share a few details about your business and current coverage, and a licensed New Jersey benefits broker will follow up. Please don’t include employee health information.
This site is an independent information resource, not an insurance agency. Inquiries are shared with a licensed New Jersey insurance producer.